- Format: Paperback
- ISBN: 978-1-5261-4591-8
- Pages: 240
- Publisher: Manchester University Press
- Price: £25.00
- Published Date: July 2019
- BIC Category: MEDICAL / Psychiatry / General, SOCIAL SCIENCE / Anthropology / General, SOCIAL SCIENCE / Islamic Studies, Psychology, Islamic Worship, Rites & Ceremonies, Medical Anthropology, Society & social sciences / Social & cultural anthropology, ethnography
- Series: Anthropology, Creative Practice and Ethnography
Over several years, Christian Suhr followed Muslim patients being treated for jinn possession and psychosis in a Danish mosque and in a psychiatric hospital. Through rich filmic and textual case studies, he shows how the bodies and souls of Muslim patients become a battlefield between the moral demands of Islam and the psychiatric institutions of European nation-states.
The book reveals how both psychiatric and Islamic healing work to produce relief from pain, and also entail an ethical transformation of the patient and the cultivation of religious and secular values through the experience of pain. Creatively exploring the analytic possibilities provided by the use of a camera, both text and film show how disruptive ritual techniques are used in healing to destabilise individual perceptions and experiences of agency, which allows patients to submit to the invisible powers of psychotropic medicine or God.
'In this stunning and beautifully written book, Christian Suhr offers us unique insights into encounters between psychiatry and spirit possession in Islamic diasporic communities. Like the accompanying film, the book is caring and thought-provoking. This is a must-read (and must-see!) not only for students and scholars of Islam, and of psychiatry, but also for all who want to think seriously about how form can be put to work conceptually-how montage, for instance, can become a mode of analysis. '
Amira Mittermaier, University of Toronto
'This book and film plumb a boundary that counts above all others in Islam and arguably in every religion: the divide between the seen and unseen worlds. By focusing on jinn possession and exorcism, the author exposes the extent to which the alam al-ghayb, or unseen world, informs the mundane, day-to-day existence of Muslims within it. Christian Suhr is a remarkably gifted auteur and a highly self-reflexive critic of audiovisual media. What he has to say regarding the possibilities and limitations of this medium for Islamic studies is far reaching. This book and film matter. '
Simon O'Meara, SOAS University of London
'A powerful contribution to anthropological understandings of spirit possession and Islamic exorcism and a ground breaking work in the field of audio-visual anthropology. Exceptionally clear and well-written; a joy to read. In ethnographic approach as well as theoretical radicalism this book is second to none in contemporary visual anthropology.'
Michaela Schäuble, University of Bern
'It seems to rain a great deal in Denmark. With the rain, angels descend to feed plants, bless homes, wash the city, and generally watch over its residents. Christian Suhr's ethnographic film, Descending with angels, considers what comes down with the rain, as Suhr maneuvers between and through Islamic healing practices and the Danish psychiatric system. The film accomplishes something unique in participatory sequences in which Suhr and the doctors, shaykhs, Muslim patients, and Muslim youth attempt to make sense of what they are seeing, from footage Suhr has shot to online Islamic exorcism videos. Descending with angels provides a complex picture of Muslim life in Denmark, from the diversity of Muslim immigrant communities to the transcultural spaces between medicine, religion, social services, and community. It dives into and evokes the liminal and transgressive, avoiding totalizing narratives and burdens of information while also getting at what it means to believe, whether in magic or Western medicine. The film offers a productive point for pedagogical departure for classes concerned with Islam and Islamic healing, immigration, consciousness and mental illness, religion and science, public health, ethnographic ethics and reflexivity, and visual anthropology.'
Maryam Kashani, University of Illinois, American Anthropologist, June 2018
'This monograph and film constitute a challenging, thought-provoking, and insightful piece of scholarship that reflects an unusually deep engagement with a difficult field of research. With a strong sense of purpose, and respect for his subject and collaborators, Suhr has produced an impressively rich ethnography, often of a highly intimate nature. The core questions have to do with the nature (and the effectiveness) of neo-orthodox Islamic healing and Danish psychiatry, but also with the possibility of intercultural cohabitation: the urgent questions of today's Denmark, Europe, and the ghettoized and globalized world in which we live.'
Laura U. Marks, Simon Fraser University
'Descending with angels delivers a compelling exegesis of the way that faith is integrated into secular society through the particular lens of psychiatric illness and spirit possession. Both elements of this work make a huge contribution to medical anthropology and Islamic studies. Suhr's reflections on methodology contribute significantly to the development of film as a research method as well as a means for broadening scholarly expression. The accessibility of this work will be appealing to students and scholars as well as to professionals involved in the treatment of mental disorders.'
Andy Lawrence, University of Manchester
Christian Suhr's film monograph Descending with Angels is a remarkable contribution to medical anthropology studies of mental health and ritual healing. Descending with Angels will be a highly relevant and most engaging read (and watch) to medical anthropologists, visual anthropologists, and those working on possession rituals.
Entanglement, Paola Esposito
The volume (book & documentary) is a multifaceted anthropological endeavor and can be read and reread from various angles. Suhr is a masterful author... His book has all the qualities of an excellent ethnography. It is an outstanding piece of a good contemporary anthropological work.
Entanglement, Maria Vivod
Christian Suhr's Descending with Angels eloquently probes the dividing lines between the sacred and the medical by comparing the Islamic practice of ruqya with psychiatric care.
Entanglement, Juliet Davies-Horn
1 Invisibility and Islamic healing in the West
2 How to take jinn possession seriously
3 Jinn exorcisms on YouTube
4 How to become a patient
5 Healing through sacrifice
6 Ruqya, psychotropics, and montage
7 No healing here
Christian Suhr is a filmmaker, Associate Professor and the Coordinator of the Eye & Mind MSc Programme in Visual Anthropology at Aarhus University